Our Hideous Progeny by C.E. McGill

Our Hideous Progeny book cover

Rating: 3/5

What It’s About:

It’s 1853 London. Ex-medical student Victor Frankenstein has been missing for years now. Frankenstein’s great niece Mary Saville and her husband, Henry, are trying to follow in his scientific footsteps and become renowned paleontologists. They have the brains and the ambition; the only thing they lack is the reputation. Mary is a woman with a sharp mind but a fierce tongue and Henry is an unemployed gambling addict: none of this earning appeal with their peers. 

But after finding clues to her great uncle’s disappearance, Mary’s luck may just change. She constructs a plan that will force the scientific community to take her and her husband seriously; no one will be able to ignore them after they learn to create life. Once they have successfully constructed their Creature, Henry’s ambition soars, but Mary finds herself asking deeper, more important questions than she’s ever confronted before. As Henry’s desire for fame grows, Mary must decide how far she is willing to go to protect the Creature she has grown to love.


Thank you to Harper and Net Galley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

The Review

The first thing of Our Hideous Progeny that caught my attention was the eye-catching cover. Looking at it, I expected to read a gothic horror. While the book did provide gothic vibes, there really wasn’t much horror to be found. Mary’s family connection to Frankenstein and the experiments that she and her husband conducted could be considered horror elements but I didn’t find them very horrifying.

Mary’s unique character didn’t fit into the mold of a stereotypical Victorian woman. What stood out the most was her struggle to fit into that mold. Mary was character was often a bit unlikeable, but I enjoyed it. She was outspoken, assertive, and often argumentative. It was empowering to see a female character that asked alot of questions, challenged the status quo, and stood up for herself in a patriarchial society.

Mary had to face many obstacles to pursue her interests in paleontology. The opportunities for women to have any type of academic career during that time period was very limited…especially in science fields. This was probably my favorite part of the book. I enjoy reading books with female characters in the STEM fields and learning about the historical aspects of it.

Another element of the book that stuck with me was the prejudice and racism that her Indian mentor experienced as a member of the scientific society. This wasn’t a major theme in the story, but it made me think about history and in a new way. In the notes at the end, the author names the real life people who inspired her characters. These included Mary Shelly (of course), Mary Anning, Mary Somerville, and Ardaseer Cursetjee Wadia.

Final thoughts

While there were several elements of Our Hideous Progeny that I enjoyed, the Frankenstein aspect of the book didn’t quite fit into the overall story. It almost felt like a gimmick to draw interest. The book was also longer than it needed to be. I would have loved to see a more realistic book of a Victorian female scientist. I think it’s a story worth telling and the Frankenstein/creation of life takes away that impact.

if you are interested in stories of women in stem fields or non-traditional careers, you might enjoy these books:

All The Pretty Places by Joy Calloway

Rating: 3/5 What It’s About: Rye, New York, 1893. Sadie Fremd’s dreams hinge on her family’s nursery, which has been the supplier of choice for respected landscape architects on the East Coast for decades. Now her small town is in a panic as the economy plummets into a depression, and Sadie’s father is pressuring her to…

Once There Were Wolves by Charlotte McConaghy

Rating: 3/5 What It’s About: Inti Flynn arrives in Scotland with her twin sister, Aggie, to lead a team of biologists tasked with reintroducing fourteen gray wolves into the remote Highlands. She hopes to heal not only the dying landscape, but Aggie, too, unmade by the terrible secrets that drove the sisters out of Alaska.…

The Candlelit Menagerie by Caraline Brown

Rating: 2.5/5 What It’s About: Set in late eighteenth-century London, this debut novel features Lillian, a freakishly tall woman who struggles to fit into society because of her size and desire to wear trousers. Each morning, she wakes in her tiny maid’s room in a too-small bed to the sound of a lion roaring nearby,…

Illuminations: a novel of Hildegard von Bingen

Rating: 3/5 Illuminations by Mary Sharrat What It’s About: One of the most extraordinary women of the Middle Ages, Hildegard von Bingen—Benedictine abbess, healer, composer, saint—experienced mystic visions from a very young age. Offered by her noble family to the Church at the age of eight, she lived for years in forced silence. But through…

Leave a Reply